Positive Reviews
positive:
Location feels secluded.
Guests staying at the Banana Bay Resort & Marina report that, despite being located in an urban area, the resort has a secluded feel to it. With a private beach and pool area, and looking out onto the Gulf of Mexico, guests describe the resort grounds as peaceful and tranquil.
positive:
Adults only resort receives approval.
Banana Bay Resort & Marina is an adult only resort, with anybody under the age of 21 not being granted permission to stay. Spring breakers are also prohibited. Guests report that this adds a peaceful and carefree atmosphere to their stay.
positive:
Picturesque pool area and beach.
According to reports, the resort grounds are picturesque and appealing. Jungle-like greenery is dotted around the pool and hot tub area while the small beach is said to be a nice touch. Guests report that the waterfront location offers terrific sunset views too.
Negative Reviews
negative:
Property requires renovation.
While many guests enjoy their stay at the Banana Bay Resort & Marina, others report that the aging property is in need of a makeover. Shabby décor, town furnishings, tired paintwork, faulty appliances and stained carpets are some of the more common issues identified.
negative:
Away from Key West's main tourist district.
The resort's location may prove tranquil for some guests but others report that the hotel is a little too far off the beaten tourist path for their liking. The resort is located by Garrison Bright at what is considered the entrance to the Old Town, placing it about two miles from Duval Street and Key West's major attractions.
negative:
Hot tub needs updating.
The resort's outdoor hot tub is popular with guests looking to unwind but according to reports the facility is in need of an upgrade. Guests report that whilst it is clean, it can be a little uncomfortable.