Positive Reviews
positive:
In the heart of Manhattan.
City Rooms NYC is located in the heart of Manhattan. The likes of Madison Square Garden, the Empire State Building, Macy's, and Times Square are all within a mile of the hotel, while Penn Station, for those arriving at Newark Airport, is just three blocks away.
positive:
Basic but clean accommodations.
Although accommodations are fairly basic, guests report that rooms are kept clean and well-maintained. This proves ample for those travellers simply looking for somewhere to rest their weary head after a day of sightseeing.
positive:
Helpful staff on hand.
Past guests have been quick to praise the hotel staff. According to reports, employees are friendly and helpful, be it offering tourist advice or helping carry luggage upstairs.
Negative Reviews
negative:
Shared bathroom unpopular with some.
Some guests choosing to lodge at City Rooms NYC are disappointed by the shared bathroom arrangements. The hotel does not offer any en suite bedrooms, meaning guests are required to use communal bathrooms. Reports indicate these are kept clean though.
negative:
Hotel lacks an elevator.
Some guests find the lack of an elevator to be an issue. Access to the hotel's upper floors is via a stairwell, which can be troublesome for those with mobility issues.
negative:
Thin walls, Eighth Avenue make for a noisy stay.
A number of guests complain about noise levels during their stay. According to some, the hotel walls are fairly thin, making it easy to hear what is going on in rooms around you. Meanwhile, traffic and street noise from Eighth Avenue can prove distracting for some.